It’s been two weeks since Nguyen Tuong Van met his maker on the road to drug trafficking riches and he is mostly gone and forgotten. What hasn’t been forgotten is the reaction of some to his death. Some 4,000 people attended his funeral in Melbourne, a city that had previously denied a digger the right to having his casket covered with the Australian flag and in Brisbane, the Premier, ordered a minutes silence in the House to mark his demise.
This act alone inflamed the sensitivities of all of us who consider a minutes silence as a mark of respect for those who have died in the service of their country or community or have been the victims of terrorist obscenities such as Bali. In noway should it ever become a political statement as was Beatties call.
I have reproduced two letters to Beattie, one from the Persident of the Royal Australian Regiment Association (Qld) and one from the President of the Qld RSL. I have deliberately delayed the posting of these letters to allow time for receipt and answer by Premier Beattie.
We wait in vain.
6 December, 2005
Premier Beattie,
Your decision to have the Queensland Parliament observe a minute silence in remembrance of Nguyen Tuong Van is considered offensive, disrespectful and an insult to Australian veterans and Australian families who have lost loved ones in service to Australia and in natural and man made disasters.
The Royal Australian Regiment Association (Qld), the largest Army Association in the State, is appalled at your decision. It unanimously directed me to express their disgust to you. Never before have I seen such solidarity of the ex-service community with any one issue.
By your act, under the explanation as “a mark of respect for the sanctity of human life??? you have successfully alienated yourself and your Government from the services community. Most people do respect the sanctity of human life and choose to display that in a private and personal way.
We will not let you demean the tribute principle of a minutes silence as a mark of respect for those who gave their lives in the service of their country or were victims of natural or man made disasters, by linking it to any convicted criminal.
Duty First
Lieutenant Colonel Ted Chitham MC (Retd)
President
Naturally enough, as of Friday, the letter from the President remains unanswered.
6 December 2005
The Hon Peter Beattie MP
Premier of Queensland
PO Box 15185
City East QLD 4002
Dear Mr Premier
I write on behalf of the Returned & Services League of Australia (Queensland Branch)
members in regards to the minute?s silence that was observed in Queensland Parliament
on Friday 2 December on the occasion of the execution of Nguyen Tuong Van.
The RSL was deeply offended and strongly opposed to the Parliamentary move to
recognise this event through a one-minute silence and we are extremely disappointed in
your leadership in this matter.
Our vehement opposition is rooted in the apparent disregard for the concept of silence for
remembrance of departed comrades, who have sacrificed their lives and health for the
sake our nation.
Our members strongly believe the decision to move the moment?s silence showed a
complete disregard for the origins of remembrance silence, which is attributed to
Australian journalist and returned serviceman, Edward Honey. Honey?s appeal for five
silent minutes of national remembrance in 1919 was the beginning of what he described
as a ?very sacred intercession?.communion with the Glorious Dead who won us peace??
The concept of remembrance silence remains an essential feature of commemorative
services and League functions to this day. No matter how small, members stand in
silence for a brief interval to remember their departed comrades.
The RSL believes it is totally inappropriate to start using the moment’s silence for any
other circumstance. To do so otherwise, is offensive to our veterans, war widows, and all
those who have lost loved ones in the service of our nation.
The fact that Queensland Parliament publicly bestowed the same honour and mark of
respect reserved for those who have paid the ultimate sacrifice, on one who has been
convicted of a criminal offence, was insulting and disrespectful.
Furthermore, as Chairman of the ANZAC Day Commemoration Committee (Queensland)
Incorporated, we believe you have a responsibility to uphold the objects of the Association,
specifically:
– the recognition of the gallant courage displayed by the Australian sons and
daughters in fighting for the preservation of liberty and civilisation; and
– the commemoration of our fallen and the acknowlegement of the suffering of our
wounded.
We strongly urge you, as Premier of Queensland, to exercise more appropriate discretion
in future to preserve the sanctity of the minute?s silence so it remains as it was intended to
be ? a very sacred intercession.
Lest We Forget.
Yours truly,
GW Mason
State President
Returned & Services League of Australia (Queensland Branch)